National Geographic

VOICES Voices Icon Ideas and Insight From Explorers

Menu

Inside the Secrets of Illusions & Memory

Michael Sweeney is the author of “Brainworks: The Mind Bending Science of What You See, How You Think, and Who You Are,” the companion book to Brain Games, a three-part series on the National Geographic Channel premiering this weekend around the globe. The book and show both make you the test subject in an array of astonishing challenges and experiments. Here, Sweeney discusses some of the book’s most surprising optical illusions, and how learning the inner workings of the brain has made him a happier person.

 

Did writing about how the brain works come naturally to you?

Even with my method of trying to become as well-read and to talk to as many people as I can, there are still things about this book that were really hard for someone who’s not a neuroscientist to write. This really stretched my brain and made it hurt, terribly.

The problem is even science doesn’t really know all the ways the brain does what it does. I’m stunned at how complicated it is. [For example with color vision,] I do my very best work trying to explain it in plain English [and my editor just shakes his head and says,] “nice try there, guy.”

Hardest thing I’ve ever tried to write about–ever: trying to explain how color vision works.

 

Did anything in the book freak you out?

There’s a picture of wheels of blue and yellow. This is a static image, but as you look at it, it’s moving. And your rational mind says that can’t be moving, that’s ink on paper, and that yet, there it is. And so your eyes tell you one thing and your brain tells you another, and they can’t both be right.

This is the phenomenon of adaptation. When your cone cells become tired of looking at the same color, they will fire it more weakly to the brain after a while, and therefore the color they’re associated with (and here I go trying to explain color vision, and I’ve already told you its really hard) but [the other color in the] pair they’re associated with–red/green, blue/yellow–fires more strongly. All of a sudden if one color on one cone starts firing differently than it did a moment before, you can have this illusion of movement as the color changes and shifts from cone to cone to cone to cone. And so these wheels turn if we stare at them. Especially in our peripheral vision because the cones are concentrated in the center of your vision, and they’re scattered more widely in the edges.

It moves! and yet it doesn’t move. I feel like Galileo here.

(Related: The World’s Oldest Optical Illusion Found?)

 

What was the most surprising thing for you?

When I did the research about how memories actually are formed, I learned that memories are stored in various parts of the brain associated with the initial sensations. So the color is stored one place and the sound is stored one place, and the associations are stored throughout. So when you call up a memory, you’re not just pulling a video tape out of a cabinet, you’re pulling jigsaw puzzle pieces out of boxes stored in all sorts of closets, and you’re putting the puzzle together.

And then–this is what really threw me–we think that these memories are permanent. They’re not.

When you pull up these bits of memory from random access in your brain, they get stuck to other things you associate with them. So they’re all jumbled up together and I may put two pieces together that don’t belong together, and then refile them, and from then on, I’ve created a memory.

By golly, I read that and I [was] stunned at how easy it is to either remember things that you think you knew, but remember them wrongly, or to have someone suggest something to you and that screws you up. [In fact,] New Jersey just passed a law that makes eye witness testimony more subject to questioning for its validity in court testimony.

 

Should this information change how we treat our minds and our perception?

It’s a post-modernist world. I teach this with my graduate students. One of the things we have to wrestle with is “how do we know what we know.” You shouldn’t have total confidence in virtually anything that you know. Because the world’s not out there, the world’s in here. This is our total perception.

If it’s true that these illusions are evidence that the brain is filling in gaps to make nice seamless narratives, then the brain is actively constructing reality. And  if that’s true, then my constructed reality is valid for me but it may be different than your constructed reality which is valid for you.

 

That sounds like it could lead some people into aimless despair…

You could say, well on one hand you’re just the victim of all these random electrons firing in your brain and it’s all a mechanical process, but I say no, I’m active, I get to emphasize some thing over another, and choose some thing over another, and if I get things wrong? That’s part of who I am. I’m constructing my vision not only of the world but of myself and I’m comfortable with that.

So I am much less certain about the world, and much happier about it.

[Editor's Note:  Or as Dumbledore once said to Harry Potter, “Of course it is happening inside your head, Harry, but why on earth should that mean that it is not real?”]

 

Listen to another conversation with Michael Sweeney and Boyd Matson on NG Weekend:

Audio clip: Adobe Flash Player (version 9 or above) is required to play this audio clip. Download the latest version here. You also need to have JavaScript enabled in your browser.

 

More Mind Bending Fun

Tune In to Brain Games on the National Geographic Channel Sunday, October 9th

Watch Brain Games Video Clips

Try Brain Games Puzzles and More

Outside the US? Visit natgeotv.com

 

 

Comments

  1. 10zen
    November 28, 2012, 9:30 am

    motion picture is really nice.
    The second and black&white pics are interesting.
    Got eyes watery staring at the pic. Amazing seeing color in black & white pic.

    http://mindpowerlibrary.com/

  2. RIFATH ANJUM SHAIK
    kuwait ,khaitan
    October 27, 2012, 3:00 am

    i am really sorry but i didnt get any pics of optical illusion

  3. moshin
    hukkeri
    October 27, 2011, 9:45 am

    wow its a best programme

  4. Sabina Epstein
    1859, Atumplace, Encinitas, Sandeigo, california
    October 26, 2011, 10:16 pm

    wow!

  5. Salman
    meerut
    October 17, 2011, 10:59 am

    tell me length and breadth of sky or is it end somewhere or not ?

  6. Frederico margarheti
    buenos aries
    October 16, 2011, 10:54 pm

    Is this series on every Sunday?

  7. random stoner
    NY
    October 16, 2011, 7:17 pm

    Truly, truly, amazing! The castle was a double rainbow of mystical vividness. The realness of the blue was just awe-inspiring audaciousness. Almost ‘SUR-real’! Wow guys, you are really outdoing yourselves with these new brain teasers. Especially with the new fantastically magical show, “Brain Games”. Way to go!
    One Luv ;)

  8. [...] Inside the Secrets of Illusion [...]

  9. Dr Chick
    CA
    October 9, 2011, 2:45 pm

    We have a lifetime of practice at ignoring unessential sensory input. Those who are more perceptive have a bigger challenge but also more frequently encounter unexpected sensory delights. Psychotropic substances can provide a conduit to this hidden world. Hesse’s “The magic theatre, not for everyone”.

  10. BinDuTheSage
    Space
    October 9, 2011, 9:59 am

    This understanding has been around since the earliest of minds. These people were considered the “enlightened ones”. Except they just got to the point quicker, by realizing that what we see is an illusion, and the mind is an auditory illusion of sound. So in this dream we’re experiencing, it is in fact life that chose us, and life that manifests energy that is within us. Life is the doer, not man.

  11. Omar
    Syria (سوريا)
    October 9, 2011, 9:39 am

    Enthusiastic to read that book…. I hope to find all my answers there.
    Thanks…

  12. Cindy Rhoades
    Between Mallorca, Spain & Key West, FL
    October 9, 2011, 3:42 am

    This research has important sociological implications and it would be important to to look at theory regarding the social construction of reality.

  13. Lyubov' Smirnova
    Russia, Moscow
    October 9, 2011, 2:50 am

    Amazing!

  14. martial cyr sylvain Marti
    프랑스
    October 9, 2011, 2:38 am

    Thank you for you information
    Truth very infortant memory….animal have also…
    And magitaion and MERKABH ,MHD,HAARP,ELOHIM,Art of soun,soun wave salt,UFO,IMfinty

  15. Lo – puzzle – and behold! « abOva
    October 8, 2011, 11:55 pm

    [...] Inside the Secrets of Illusions & Memory – News Watch. Share this:TwitterFacebookLike this:LikeBe the first to like this post. [...]

  16. Diego
    Argentina
    October 8, 2011, 11:52 pm

    It moves…. Awsome!!!

  17. Hongsun
    October 8, 2011, 11:12 pm

    Love that notion of yours. Maybe from now on, I’ll creat my own world and be extremely happy and free with it, also ignore what people tell or teach me about the world (actually their world).

  18. Diane Hinkle
    Columbus, Ohio
    October 8, 2011, 10:27 pm

    The wheel picture doesn’t move for me! I wonder why that is, and whether it’s related to the difficulty I have perceiving those computer-generated embedded pictures. Any ideas? I should also mention I have very acute senses.

  19. Amit Mishra
    India
    October 8, 2011, 10:11 pm

    A very knowledgable piece of work. . It will help us understand things much better and more deeply. . Author was at his best. . . :)

  20. Andrew Howley
    October 8, 2011, 9:54 pm

    Indeed I do, Claudia, thanks for sharing it.

  21. Marlene
    SP/Brasil
    October 8, 2011, 9:42 pm

    Fabuloso! adorei! assistir toda a série desse p;rograma.

  22. karen French-hall
    kalamazoo mi
    October 8, 2011, 9:33 pm

    love your view of memory storage and connections to color empahsis recall. I am an art teacher and allow this exploration. Encourage it actually. thank you……..more please

  23. D
    California Md
    October 8, 2011, 9:17 pm

    Good job with the building of that thought. The yellow and blue stuck out in my mind. The idea of turning off or filtering the nerve that controls just the color blue. My favorite color is blue. When i think of blue i think of many things that are blue. But what brings the objective side to the process. Suddenly something not blue.

  24. Claudia
    New York
    October 8, 2011, 9:10 pm

    Very interested post. Mr. Howley, you will like my photo of a sunflower with the Fraser’s optical illusion on it!!

    http://ngm.nationalgeographic.com/ngm/photo-contest/2011/entries/81580/view/

  25. Anita
    October 8, 2011, 6:22 pm

    But don’t optical illusions such as the one above also work in black and white? That uses the rods, not the cones. What allows that to work?