VOICES Voices Icon Ideas and Insight From Explorers

Menu

Watch: Fish and Eels Team Up to Catch Prey—Rare Among Animals

Talk about lending a helping “fin”—groupers and eels in a coral reef work together to catch prey, a new study says.

Previously, scientists had thought only humans and chimpanzees collaborated in this way, suggesting that teamwork may be more widespread in the animal kingdom than thought. (Also see “Groupers Use Gestures to Recruit Morays For Hunting Team-Ups.”)

When prey is out of reach in a crevasse in the western Pacific Ocean, the big, red grouper—actually called a coral trout—will shimmy back and forth in front of a moray eel, essentially “asking” the moray eel for help in flushing out its victim. (Also see “Fish ‘Engineers’ Dig Up Homes for Marine Life.”)

Though shimmying conveys “let’s go hunting” in aquatic sign language, not all moray eels are created equal. The research, published September 8 in Current Biology, shows that coral trout are able to learn and remember which individual moray eel is best for the job and return to that one again and again. In return, the moray eel gets to eat whatever the coral trout can’t catch.

“This study makes us take a step back and think about how the cooperative behavior we’ve seen in chimpanzees doesn’t just exist because they are so similar to [humans],” said David Steen, a wildlife ecologist at Auburn University in Alabama who was not involved with the study.

“Perhaps we should acknowledge that a wide variety of animals can engage in exciting and advanced behaviors that we previously had thought helped distinguish us,” he said by email.

Go Fish

For the experiment, scientists at the University of Cambridge in England and the University of Neuchâtel in Switzerland re-created a typical hunting scenario in the lab with captive coral trout.

The researchers made two puppet moray eels, one of which was deemed helpful and the other unhelpful.

When the coral trout visited the unhelpful “moray eel” and did their shimmies, the scientists-turned-puppet-masters had the moray swim in the wrong direction. However, when the fish approached the helpful moray, it would effectively do its job, and the fish was rewarded with dinner. (Also see “Pictures: Sharks Taught to Hunt Alien Lionfish.”)

After 48 trials over the course of six days, the coral trout learned which moray eel could help it achieve its goals, and would enlist that moray’s assistance, said study leader Alex Vail, a marine biologist at Cambridge.

Brain Power

The study is an advance, but it brings up a lot more questions than it answers, said Tom Kwak, a fisheries ecologist at the U.S. Geological Survey’s North Carolina Cooperative Fish and Wildlife Research Unit who wasn’t involved in the research.

For instance, the next step is to explain how the fish are able to carry out these complicated tasks with such limited processing power.

A photo of a coral grouper being cleaned by a shrimp.
A coral grouper (Plectropomus leopardus), also called a coral trout or leopard coral grouper, gets its mouth cleaned by a clear cleaner shrimp in the Maldives in 2009. Photograph by Jason Isley, Scubazoo/Science Faction/Corbis

A fish’s brain is much simpler than that of a chimp or person because it has far fewer nerve connections.

It’s possible that fish get around this limitation by using their brains very efficiently, but that’s unknown. (Read “Minds of Their Own” in National Geographic magazine.)

“[Humans] think about something we want and try a whole bunch of ways to achieve it. Do animals think it through or do they just do a behavior?

“We have to work out what kind of mental processes they use to do these collaborations.”

Whatever the mechanism, noted Culum Brown, a biologist at Macquarie University in Sydney, “fish are far smarter than most people give [them] credit [for].”

Follow Mollie Bloudoff-Indelicato on Twitter.

Comments

  1. 4rensik
    New Zealand
    September 11, 2014, 4:55 pm

    Here in New Zealand the eel was part of the Maori diet, mainly smoked. The Maori name is “Tuna” using our vowels, so not the english tuna (fish) as most would know it. Eel’s have now become a delicacy as the New Zealand population has grown and restrictions and quota’s are being placed on most of the traditional Maori kai (food). Also, European’s have started to serve eel in their restaurants.

  2. Capt. O
    September 9, 2014, 10:34 am

    I have had four foot barracuda shadow me like a dog at heal, not three feet off my left shoulder, as I spearfished in shallows before. I’d poke around a little coral head or rock, out would shoot a small fish and the barracuda would strike like a lightning bolt. There’d be some scales floating to the bottom and as soon as the meal had been swallowed, the barracuda would be back in place waiting for the next bite. Did this for hours over a week’s time. Seems very much like inter species cooperation to me although I did most of the work for very little reward!

  3. Luciano Lucci
    Faenza (Italy)
    September 9, 2014, 10:06 am

    Amazing colours ! 😀

  4. james nyakuni
    kenya africa maasai mara
    September 9, 2014, 2:00 am

    i will like to be sending photos to you guys i have nice love photos thanks national geographic

  5. Dianne Strycharz
    United States
    September 8, 2014, 9:14 pm

    After watching NOVA on PBS, I’m not too surprised – I think many animals are more intelligent than we think!

  6. Fr3d
    September 8, 2014, 8:03 pm

    Humans have much too high an opinion of ourselves. We really need to take a different look at the definition of intelligence. Many animals have been described as having the intelligence of a two year old. A kid at two years can have an amazing mental grasp on his environment.

  7. Raynald Metilus
    Haïti
    September 8, 2014, 5:09 pm

    This true , I always go swimming in the ocean and I saw that once!