Menu

OPINION: Hong Kong’s Infamous and Shadowy Ivory Trade

By Alex Hofford

It is a little known fact that the blame for the elephant poaching crisis of the 1980s, which resulted in the global ivory ban of 1989, can be laid squarely at the feet of the Hong Kong ivory traders. And now they’re at it again.

At a time when it has been scientifically proven that Africa lost 100,000 elephants from 2010 through 2012, no one in Hong Kong is questioning why the city’s ivory traders are still clinging onto their old stocks of ivory, which should have been depleted long ago.

It’s a moral outrage that these old men, who have had more than 25 years to clear out their pre-1989 ban ivory stocks, are still holding onto them.

Or are they simply pulling the wool over the eyes of the Hong Kong Agriculture, Fisheries and Conservation Department (AFCD) and topping up their existing stocks of pre-1989 convention ivory with illegally smuggled ivory fresh off the boat from Mombasa?

Hong Kong Ivory Seizures on the Increase

The recent spate of ivory seizures intercepted by the Hong Kong Customs & Excise Department with alarming and increasing regularity at Hong Kong’s port and airport would seem to suggest as much.

 

Confiscated ivory from Ivory Coast in Africa is seen at the Hong Kong Customs & Excise Department Ports and Maritime Command Centre, Kwai Chung, Kowloon, Hong Kong, 03 October 2013. Copyright Alex Hofford.
Confiscated ivory from Ivory Coast in Africa is seen at the Hong Kong Customs & Excise Department Ports and Maritime Command Centre, Kwai Chung, Kowloon, Hong Kong, 03 October 2013. Copyright Alex Hofford.

 

It’s a mystery to wildlife conservationists and animal welfare advocates in Hong Kong that with such high demand from the surging number of Chinese tourists coming here, many of whom have woefully low awareness of the poaching crisis in Africa, the total amount of “legal” ivory in the hands of the trade has barely moved more than a few kilos in the past three years.

According to Hong Kong government statistics, it was 116.5 tonnes in 2011, 118.7 tonnes in 2012, and 117.1 tonnes in 2013. Why isn’t this stockpile going down?

It’s an open secret that many tourists who come to Hong Kong smuggle ivory products back home. Wildlife crime is still not being taken seriously in this Special Administrative Region of the People’s Republic of China.

Fines and penalties for ivory trafficking remain low, as can be seen by the paltry, “slap-on-the-wrist” sentences of six months handed down by a Hong Kong magistrate to 16 Vietnamese ivory traffickers caught red-handed at Hong Kong airport in June.

 

Click on chart to enlarge it
Click on chart to enlarge it

 

Let’s be clear: Hong Kong people aren’t buying this stuff. Tourists are indirectly fueling an ivory trade that forms an integral part of the global illegal wildlife trade—the fourth largest type of illegal trafficking after drugs, arms, and human beings.

Hong Kong is not immune from the scourge of Islamic terrorism, and many consumers are unaware that by buying an ivory trinket from a store in Mong Kok, Sheung Wan, or North Point, they could just be financing terrorist militias in Africa like Al-Shabaab, Boko Haram, or Lord’s Resistance Army.

The numbers on the WildLifeRisk graph show that Hong Kong ivory traders are topping up their supposed legal stocks with freshly poached ivory from Africa.

We at Hong Kong for Elephants doubt that Hong Kong’s AFCD is carrying out much more than very cursory inspections of the keeping premises of the ivory stock held by the 447 anonymous holders of ivory possession licenses. Does AFCD go deeper than merely checking whether or not those licenses are up-to-date? We doubt it.

Hong Kong Should Step Up

The unfolding crisis affecting Africa’s iconic megafauna is a cause for concern for all, and Hong Kong does have a role to play as a responsible global player.

Unfortunately, these days it is not only the sharks that we need to look out for. We also need each and everyone to stop buying ivory. The Hong Kong government could do so much more to raise awareness about this urgent issue. They could do a lot worse than start by legislating an ivory trade ban to save the magnificent African elephant before it’s too late.

Alex Hofford is founder of Hong Kong for Elephants and a wildlife campaigner for WildAid. @alexhofford

 

A photo made available 19 June 2013 shows a rhinoceros figurine made out of ivory at a store selling ivory products in Kowloon, Hong Kong, China, 19 June 2013. Dr Poole, who is based in Kenya, is China to meet with zoo directors, government officials and animal welfare groups to discuss the ivory issue. More than 7 per cent of the world's elephants were killed for their tusks in 2012, which is the highest recorded amount, according to the researcher. 40 per cent of ivory poached in Africa is bound for China, which sis still the biggest market for elephant tusks. Poole is urging the governments of Beijing and Hong Kong to ban the trade. Copyright Alex Hofford.
A photo made available 19 June 2013 shows a rhinoceros figurine made out of ivory at a store selling ivory products in Kowloon, Hong Kong, China, 19 June 2013. Copyright Alex Hofford.

Comments

  1. Oliver Wales-Smith
    Zimbabwe
    November 17, 2014, 5:14 am

    We need to petition the Hong Kong Government for a full ban of ivory in Hong Kong. This ban must include trafficking, selling and buying ivory. People caught trafficking ivory must be given very high sentences. We need to do this now to save the elephants. Let’s take action!

  2. Donald Nigro
    Hawaii
    September 30, 2014, 5:40 am

    continued: are impermissible, too. Theirs is nothing more than a cultural war aimed at antiquarians, both dealers and collectors of vintage and antique ivory artifacts… and equally innocent heirs whose heretofore windfalls would be reduced to so much worthless and unsalable bric-a-brac. This is not a case of a shared burden for a greater good; but an instance of ill-advised and unnecessary collateral damage to innocent Americans. Simply put, ANIMAL RIGHTS NEED NOT TRAMPLE HUMAN RIGHTS. It’s a shame some can’t grasp this concept and are intent on inflicting their draconian measures worldwide unto the innocent as well as the guilty.

  3. Donald Nigro
    Hawaii
    September 30, 2014, 5:09 am

    It’s good that true culprits in Hong Kong, China and Africa are being singled out. Unfortunately the radical animal rights activists aren’t satisfied with that. They are intent to wipe out the vintage and antique ivory trade in America as well. They and their ilk, won’t be happy until little old ladies have their heirloom ivory earrings ripped off their earlobes at airports or proud Hawaiians are forced to surrender their ancestral lei Niho Palaoa at airports or face federal charges if they resist. Apparently human rights mean nothing to these folks. Established, heretofore legal pre-bans ivory, and American cottage industries past usages with old stock ivory like musical instrument fittings, weaponry fittings and vintage and antique jewelry and statuary

  4. Taura
    US
    September 29, 2014, 9:09 am

    It’s time we stopped the heartless slaughter of elephants. The ivory traders must be stopped!!!

  5. Gwenda Wheeler
    England
    September 29, 2014, 4:55 am

    Lack of knowledge is not an excuse ivory comes from elephants to get it the elephant has to be killed.

  6. julie ahlstrom
    australia
    September 29, 2014, 4:42 am

    The people who are still buying ivory are without hearts I don`t believe for one minute that they are not aware of the horror that is being inflicted on these magical creatures. Life imprisonment for poachers and traders alike that would be a start

  7. diane melville
    Vancouver Island B C Canada
    September 28, 2014, 8:23 pm

    Please stop the brutality!!!!!!!!!

  8. Rosemary Fox
    Smithers, Canada
    September 28, 2014, 4:47 pm

    With modern media, there is no excuse for people to be ignorant of the impacts of the ivory trade on wild elephants and rhinos..
    Penalties need to be really punitive.

  9. elizabeth harrington
    united kingdom
    September 28, 2014, 3:01 pm

    Sop killing elephant and rhino!!! Stop killing all our precious wildlife! I encourage you to watch closely on 4th October 2014 and see how many people around the world want a ban on ivory and want the slaughter to STOP! You must listen.

  10. elaine russo
    September 28, 2014, 1:33 pm

    maybe we should kill the carvers of the ivory!

  11. alan mitchell
    September 28, 2014, 1:30 pm

    HONG KONG YOU ARE KILLERS. STOP KILLING ELEPHANTS AND RHINOS FOR THERE IVORY. ITS DISGUSTING. …THOSE WHO OWN IT ARE MURDERERS.
    THIS IS THE 21st CENTURY GET A GRIP.STOP STOP STOP.

  12. alan mitchell
    United Kingdom
    September 28, 2014, 1:26 pm

    HONG KONG….YOU ARE KILLERS STOP KILLING WHAT IS NOT YOURS. THIS IS THE 21st CENTURY WERE HUMAN BEINGS DONT KILL FOR PLESURE.

  13. George Deprelle
    Belgique
    September 28, 2014, 1:19 pm

    Freedom for Hong Kong people = YES
    Murder of Elephants,Rhinos,Sharks etc by Hong Kong Mafia = NO

  14. irene kleiner
    schwitzerland
    September 27, 2014, 10:56 am

    stoppt diesen horror endlich!