Menu

Mountain Lions Versus Black Bears

A cinnamon American black bear, peers up at circling ravens. The bear stands claim over an elk killed by a mountain lion in northwest Wyoming. Photograph by Mark Elbroch / Panthera.
A cinnamon American black bear, peers up at circling ravens. The bear stands claim over an elk killed by a mountain lion in northwest Wyoming. Photograph by Mark Elbroch / Panthera.

F96, nicknamed Frostbite because of the loss of parts of her ears and the tip of her tail during the winter of 2012-13, is a young female mountain lion followed as part of Panthera’s Teton Cougar Project. She dispersed from her mother’s home range in May of this year, when she was 20 months old. As snow drifts melted last Spring, she launched south into unknown territory. F96 successfully killed her first deer just 75 meters from a trail frequented by joggers and mountain bikers, and peacefully consumed it while concealed by tall sagebrush sufficient to hide her comings and goings.

But April showers and May flowers brought forth more than herbaceous growth—both grizzly and black bears emerged from winter slumbers in April of this year. Typically, the large male bears emerge first, followed by subadults, and then finally females with newborn cubs. Spring bears are hungry, some of which have lost near a third of their weight while in hibernation. Thus, Spring and early Summer foods—like animal carcasses—are essential to bears for recovering depleted reserves quickly, before the distractions and energy expenditures associated with the mating season.

F96 finished her first meal, and innocently wandered north, up and over the mountain. She began hunting the cooler, forested north slopes—forests carpeted in an explosion of new green vegetation. Perhaps she didn’t know at the time, but this was also where black bears linger in Spring, grazing lush new growth like cattle and keeping cool in the shade. F96’s next five deer kills were stolen by black bears, several within hours of when she made them. What was surely a huge loss for F96, was a real boon for bears.

 

F96, a young female mountain lion followed by Panthera's Teton Cougar Project.
F96 (nicknamed Frostbite), a young female mountain lion followed by Panthera’s Teton Cougar Project. Still beautiful without the tips of her ears. Photograph by Mark Elbroch / Panthera.

Bear kleptoparasitism (kleptoparasitism is science-talk for “stealing food from another animal”) is ubiquitous wherever bears and mountain lions overlap in North America. In a Colorado study, we found that black bears visited 48% of deer and elk killed by cougars in summer, and in a California study, they visited an amazing 77% of deer killed by cougars (Elbroch et al. 2014). That’s a tremendous amount of interference by bears in cougars’ lives.

In both the CO and CA studies, cougars killed about 50% more animals each week in the “bear season” than the “no-bear season.” Our research showed that black bear kleptoparasitism likely increased cougar kill rates in two ways: first, mountain lions eat less of their kills when a bear shows up, and second, mountain lions kill their next prey more quickly when displaced by a bear at their last kill. So, when bears are around, cougars spend less time at kills, and less time between kills…both of which lead to more frequent killing of prey.

But higher mountain lion kill rates in summer are explained by more than just bear kleptoparasitism—cougars kill more prey in summer because 1) they hunt smaller prey in summer (like deer fawns and elk calves), 2) higher temperatures increase invertebrate activity (which voraciously consume dead animals, Ray et al. 2014), and 3) higher temperatures increase how quickly meat spoils (Bischoff-Mattson and Mattson 2009). One possibility is that cougars seek out smaller prey during the summer bear season to mitigate competition with black bears over carcass remains, just like cheetahs do in the presence of African lions (Hayward et al. 2006). In other words, cougars might hunt smaller prey so they can finish their meal rather than deal with the black bear(s) that inevitably shows up when there’s enough meat to attract their attention.

 

So…why don’t mountain lions defend their kills from bears? On occasion, they do. In one case in California, a large female mountain lion was displaced by an average-sized female black bear from a deer kill. The lion abandoned the site for 24 hours, but then looped back to confront the bear. What we found when we visited the kill a week later were the remains of the deer and bear, side by side. But our research has shown that this is the rare encounter. Typically mountain lions hear the approach of the bear, and don’t even stick around to spit and hiss. They just leave. Perhaps the risks of injury in a fight outweigh the loss of a meal.

F96 did abandon the bear-infested hillside to hunt elsewhere this past Spring, and then she more successfully consumed the prey she killed. But bears continued to plague her wherever she wandered. And she wasn’t alone, bears stole carcasses from all the mountain lions we followed over the course of the summer. This seems to be the way it is. Where bears and cougars overlap, cougars suffer bears stealing their kills, and frequently. Wolves, grizzly bears, people, condors (in the south) and occasionally packs of coyotes also push cougars from their kills. Life is hard for mountain lions.

The studies described in this post were just published in Behavioral Ecology, and can be found here. And please feel free to contact us through our project Facebook page, to request a copy of the full article. We’d be happy to send it to you.

Panthera logoBischoff-Mattson Z, Mattson D. 2009. Effects of simulated mountain lion caching on decomposition of ungulate carcasses. Western North American Naturalist 69:343-350.

Elbroch, L.M., Lendrum, P.E., Allen, M.L., Wittmer, H.U., 2014. Nowhere to hide: pumas, black bears, and competition refuges. Behavioral Ecology DOI:10.1093/beheco/aru189.

Hayward MW, Hofmeyr M, O’Brien J, Kerley GIH. 2006. Prey preferences of the cheetah Acinonyx jubatus Felidae: Carnivora: morphological limitations or the need to capture rapidly consumable prey before kleptoparasites arrive? Journal of Zoology 270:615–627.

Ray RR, Seibold H, Heurich M.  2014. Invertebrates outcompete vertebrate facultative scavengers in simulated lynx kills in the Bavarian Forest National Park, Germany. Anim Biodiversity and Conservation 37:77-88.

Comments

  1. Sally M.
    Ohio
    November 10, 2014, 10:41 am

    I love the article and mountain lions. The mountain lions ability to overcome this is why I love these creatures they are determined and perseverance make for the perfect A pex cat predators. I want to know how this mtn lion does. I watch animal shows a lot and see bears scare away other animals to eat after hibernating.

  2. cecilia carcamo
    Karlsruhe, Germany
    November 10, 2014, 1:43 am

    Brilliant article
    Thank you!

  3. Arthur Veitch
    Grande Cache, Alberta, Canada
    November 4, 2014, 2:29 am

    I wonder if it was really the female cougar that killed the bear. I have found that male and female cougars sometimes share kills. Perhaps it was a much larger tom that came upon and killed the black bear, caching it cat style beside the original kill. The female returned to feed and took the fall for the dastardly deed. Not saying that a female cougar couldn’t have done it but it just doesn’t sound likely.

  4. Marcus Grigato
    Blumenau - SC, Brazil
    November 2, 2014, 7:49 pm

    Great article!
    Congratulations!

  5. Marcus Grigato
    Blumenau - SC, Brazil
    November 2, 2014, 7:14 pm

    Cougars are clever avoiding the fights to defend their kills. It is essencial for their survival, But it is good to know that sometimes they are able to face and win over a bigger predator like black bears.
    It must be an incredible encounter!
    Thanks for the article!

  6. NOAH KEKOKAI
    Liberia
    November 1, 2014, 8:00 pm

    I will be happy to receive your up to date