VOICES Voices Icon Ideas and Insight From Explorers

Menu

Short Film Showcase: Growing Up Transgender and Mormon

Click here if video does not display.

Eri Hayward was born as a boy in Utah and raised in the Church of Latter-Day Saints. Filmmaker Torben Bernhard shot this poignant short, Transmormon, just before Eri flew to Thailand for sexual reassignment surgery. In the piece, she and her family talk about the long and often painful journey it took to recognize and embrace her transgender identity and the role their faith played along the way. “Being LDS was our life,” she says. “It’s one of the reasons I didn’t find out about what being trans was until I was an adult.” I spoke with Torben and Eri about the making of the film.

When did you first hear of Eri’s story?

Torben: I first heard about Eri through a collaboration with KUER 90.1 in Salt Lake City. They suggested I read a blog interview that had been conducted with her where she discussed her Mormon upbringing, evolving faith, and impending sex-reassignment surgery. When we found out that she would be leaving to Bangkok in a matter of days, we reached out to the Hayward family and were filming with them within the week.

How long did you shoot with her and her family?

Torben: Altogether, we filmed for under a week. However, the editing took roughly six months, partially because our production team all had day jobs and we created the project from our own finances.

Can you share any particularly moving or memorable feedback after the film was released?

Eri: After the video went out there was [a] huge outpouring of support. Messages, emails, Facebook friends. It was a really great experience for myself, my family, and my boyfriend. He was probably the most skeptical of it all, but once the love and support started pouring in he was pleasantly surprised. I have not been able to keep up and reply to all the messages and comments, but I do appreciate them so much!

Torben: I’ve received messages from around the world. Many people have reached out to pass kind messages onto the Hayward family and to thank us for producing the film. I’ve received personal emails from trans individuals who let me know they used the film with their own families to ease the coming out process. The support has been overwhelming. We never imagined our short documentary would one day reach such a large audience.

Has Eri’s relationship with the Church of Latter Day Saints changed over the past year?

Eri: Yes, things have changed a lot. I am no longer a member of the church, but things did not happen in the way that some might think. I met many times with my bishop at the time, who was unbelievably supportive and understanding. Surgery came and went. They informed me that as a woman I could not hold the priesthood (already knew and preferred that), and that I could not go to the temple (already was aware of that too). The main issue that I had to face was that I was a woman living with my boyfriend unmarried. Through a lot of discussion I realized that my priorities had changed, and after a formal meeting with my bishop it was decided that I would no longer be a member, and I was excommunicated. I am so much happier now, but there are no feelings of hurt or anger. It was really a great experience, where I felt a lot of love and understanding from my leaders.

What are you both working on next?

Eri: Well, I am not really doing anything special. Just living and exploring the wonderful life I have. I am trying to help people and share my experiences through panels, presenting, and such. I hope that someday it [will] become easy for people to be themselves and to support others in doing the same.

Torben: Transmormon has enabled me to work full-time in documentary. I’ve helped in various capacities on a number of films in the past year and am always on the hunt for new stories to tell. Most recently, I am editing a film covering the heroin epidemic in Utah. This short documentary completely changed the trajectory of my career, and I will forever be grateful to the Hayward family.

Short Film Showcase

The Short Film Showcase spotlights exceptional short videos created by filmmakers from around the web and selected by National Geographic editors. We look for work that affirms National Geographic’s mission of inspiring people to care about the planet. The filmmakers created the content presented, and the opinions expressed are their own, not those of the National Geographic Society. Know of a great short film that should be part of our Showcase?

Email SFS@ngs.org to submit a video for consideration.

See more from National Geographic’s Short Film Showcase.

#shortfilmshowcase @natgeo

Comments

  1. MrNirom
    Oregon
    August 26, 2015, 4:58 pm

    As a member of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints (Mormon).. I can no more explain why I was born male, feel male and attracted to the female.. than I can why she was born male, feels female and attracted to the male. Sure.. I can speculate… but it would mean very little.

    I know that until revelation is received directly about this situation, the status quo will remain.

    We do know that we are told we will be judged based on our minds, hearts and actions. When one person asked a messenger from God.. Why do babies die?.. they were told.. “They didn’t have to come here. But the lives of those they affect come in direct proportion to the amount of time they are living upon the earth”. I know of another person who found out they had made the choice in their pre-mortal life to come to this earth and experience the disease called cystic fibrosis for their lifetime.. I can only surmise that Eri as well.. was given the choice to experience what she is experiencing upon this earth. I don’t know this for a fact that this is true.. just my summation of what I know and believe.

  2. Joseph
    Port Angeles Washington
    August 26, 2015, 4:39 pm

    The world knows that National Geographic reaches the highest of refined quality and accomplished expertise as a journal and media source. That is why I’m so surprised to see it refer to the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints only as “The Church of Latter Day Saints.” While Mormons tend not to raise much kerfuffle over nomenclature, National Geographic should know that such terminology is considered derogatory with inherent implications that the Mormon Church is not Christian or worthy of respect. This is hurtful and is interpreted as a prejudgment “dig” against the faith; which National Geographic ought to be above. Good practice is found at http://www.mormonnewsroom.org/style-guide.

    There is an inherent irony, of course, in using the improper name of the church (whether intended to be judgmental or not) in an article highlighting the transgender community which has always been plagued by people refusing the proper pronouns as a form of protest against them, their state of being or their “choices.” It can be hurtful.

    Otherwise, this was a most enlightening and important article. Eri, her family and these filmmakers are worthy of praise for presenting these pressing and timely stories to the public. My heart is with them all.