Menu

Prison No Place for Our Dying Species

This article is brought to you by the International League of Conservation Photographers (iLCP). Read our other articles on the National Geographic Voices blog featuring the work of our iLCP Fellow Photographers all around the world.

Text and Photos by iLCP Fellow Paul Hilton

A diver leads a whale shark out of the holding pen and safely back to the wild. Photo © Paul Hilton
A diver leads a whale shark out of the holding pen and safely back to the wild. Photo © Paul Hilton

For many years, I’ve documented undersea life; capturing images of threatened species as they glide through vast expanses of ocean, oblivious to the fact they are prized and, therefore, mercilessly hunted by those at the top of the food chain.

 

But on this day, I am on a very different assignment. There is no freedom here, and for the whale shark that swims past me at speed, there is no escape either. This is a marine pen, housing two young sharks, on a small island in the Maluku Sea, Indonesia.

Whale sharks, shown here swimming in a netted pool, were recovered as part of an operation to prevent the illegal trade of large marine animals. Photo ©Paul Hilton
Whale sharks, shown here swimming in a netted pool, were recovered as part of an operation to prevent the illegal trade of large marine animals. Photo ©Paul Hilton

Behind a heavy mesh enclosure, the environment here is devoid of all of the sights, sounds, and smells of the natural world. The smaller of the two sharks, moves towards me; its mouth agape, begging for food. Realising I don’t have what it wants, the shark languidly swims away to make yet another, monotonous lap of this man made prison.

 

My assignment is to cover the Wildlife Conservation Society (WCS)’s 18 month long investigation into the illegal trade of live marine megafauna from Indonesia to supply the world’s ocean theme parks. It’s a ground-breaking initiative involving Indonesia’s Ministry for Marine Affairs and Fisheries, Ambon and Labuan Lombok’s Fisheries, the Maritime Affairs Monitoring Taskforce, Maritime Patrol, and the Wildlife Crimes Unit (WCU) of the WCS.

This whale shark was destined to become a victim of the illegal wildlife trade before the Indonesian Ministry of Marine Affairs and Fisheries intervened. Photo ©Paul Hilton
This whale shark was destined to become a victim of the illegal wildlife trade before the Indonesian Ministry of Marine Affairs and Fisheries intervened. Photo ©Paul Hilton

The investigations have focused on where the animals are being illegally caught and then trafficked. It emerged that China and Southeast Asia are prime locations; in China alone there are 39 known ocean theme parks built or under construction; a booming industry whose tide shows no sign of stemming. The flagship facility is Chimelong Ocean Kingdom; a giant holiday resort featuring many of the great ocean species. Opening in 2014, Chimelong Ocean Kingdom is located in Zhuhai, Guangdong Province, just outside Macao in Southern China, and boasts the world’s largest aquarium with an investment of 5 billion USD. The marine park’s website advertises whale sharks as one of it’s major attractions, as well as dolphins and manta rays.

The two sharks are siluetted against the sun in a holding pen. Photo: © Paul Hilton for WCS
The two sharks are silhouetted against the sun in a holding pen. Photo: © Paul Hilton

The China Cetacean Alliance (CCA), a coalition of international animal-protection groups reports that the facility houses 491 cetaceans, which include 279 bottlenose dolphins, 114 belugas, and nine killer whales. Most troubling is that number of exported wildlife to the centre is growing as animals die, due to lack of natural diet, and also depression. This implies yet more animals will need to be replaced, putting exponentially more pressure on dwindling wild populations.  

The team comprising the Indonesian government agencies and Wildlife Crimes Unit of the Wildlife Conservation Society arrive after dark. Photo: © Paul Hilton for WCS
The team arriving after dark. Photo: © Paul Hilton

Our investigation in Maluku was sparked in late 2014 by an undercover contact stating that he had witnessed a large oceanic manta ray being flown out of Ambon, Indonesia, by the airline Volga-Dnepr destined for Macao in China. The manta ray was destined for Zhuhai Chimelong Investment & Development Co., Ltd. However, Indonesia had declared whale sharks a protected species throughout its entire near 6 km square kilometer exclusive economic zone (EEZ) in 2013, and followed up with similar protection measures for manta rays in February 2014. The fact that exports were continuing implied a support from at least some high-level authorities when it comes to this valuable, yet illegal, enterprise.

Two whale sharks, shown here swimming in a netted pool, were recovered as part of an operation to prevent the illegal trade of large marine animals. Photo ©Paul Hilton
Two whale sharks, shown here swimming in a netted pool, were recovered as part of an operation to prevent the illegal trade of large marine animals. Photo ©Paul Hilton

A year and a half later, the trail of this email led us to the Maluku marine farm.

Arriving after dark, armed, and unannounced, our team comprising the Indonesian government law enforcement agencies and Wildlife Crimes Unit of the Wildlife Conservation Society quickly went to work. Within minutes all staff members at the facility were sitting down in a line in front of us. The questioning began.

 

An employee there told us his boss had recommendation letters from the Indonesian government officials to collect and breed ornamental fish, while applications classifying the farm as a conservation institution was apparently being processed. Such status would allow the capture, breeding, and export of whale sharks, dolphins, and manta. The employee claimed that the program was part of a “government to government exchange” between Indonesia and China, and insisted that it was fully approved by the relevant authorities.

A beluga whale swims past an onlooking crowd in an cement aquarium in China. Photo: © Paul Hilton
A beluga whale swims past an onlooking crowd in an cement aquarium in China. Photo: © Paul Hilton

However, the Ministry of Marine Affairs and Fisheries in Jakarta had no knowledge of this operation and no legal permits have yet been issued for export of whale sharks or any other live marine megafauna. Equally, there is no evidence that the Chinese authorities had issued legal import permits. At a press conference in Jakarta on Friday 27 May, the Minister of Maritime Affairs and Fisheries Susi Pudjiastuti was typically forthright and insisted that “There is no excuse for catching whale sharks as the species is fully protected under 2013 law. This is conservation. It has rules. Nothing can legalize what they have done.”

Marine Police question staff members of Pt. Air Biru Maluku.Photo: © Paul Hilton for WCS
Marine Police question staff members of Pt. Air Biru Maluku.Photo: © Paul Hilton

Climbing into the pen with the sharks, I focus on their condition after three months in captivity. Documents revealed that the company purchasing the whale sharks, Pt Air Biru Maluku, also known as Blue Aquatic International, is a company part owned by a Singaporean-Chinese businessman and a mid-ranking Indonesian military officer. The same company is known to have legally exported manta rays to Singapore’s Resorts World Sentosa, owned by the Genting Group, one of Malaysia’s largest corporations, prior to the Indonesian government’s decision to protect the species.

 

The poachers of the two sharks were to receive 20 million rupiah or US$1,476 once they had been caught. Staff at Blue Aquatic told us it costs at least US$800 to catch and keep the sharks alive, which emphasized to me once again the never-ending unanswered question in this line of work: is it really worth it?

 

Live aquarium fish dart back and forth in a sea pen. In places like Thailand and Indonesia and the Philippines these fish are collected using cyanide poisoning, which acts as an anesthetic. Photo: © Paul Hilton
Live aquarium fish dart back and forth in a sea pen. In places like Thailand and Indonesia and the Philippines these fish are collected using cyanide poisoning, which acts as an anesthetic. Photo: © Paul Hilton

At the time of writing, arrests are yet to be made, but the offenders will be charged under Indonesian Fisheries Law number 31/2004 which carries a maximum penalty of six years in prison, and fines of up to IDR 1.5 billion (approximately 115,000 USD).

 

As I take another breath and dive down to take a few last photographs of the imprisoned sharks, the team prepare to release them back into the habitat they should never have left. The staff signal they are ready, and bait the water outside the net but the sharks won’t leave the enclosure. It is astounding that their instincts have already been so affected by their three months in captivity. The smaller of the two finally crosses the line, but then turns, to head back in. I’m always loathe to intervene in the natural world, but I fear the shark’s only chance to leave the confines of the holding pen will be lost if I do not. I apply pressure to its head, directing the six metre animal towards the open water. It dives down, finally outside of the net, disappearing into the blue. I miss the shot, but the shark is back where it belongs.

A diver leads a whale shark out of the holding pen and safely back to the wild. Photo © Paul Hilton
A diver leads a whale shark out of the holding pen and safely back to the wild. Photo © Paul Hilton

I knew, however, the next shot was a “must get”. As I turned around, a diver was escorting the larger shark out, yet I managed to capture the image; a positive illustration that I truly hope will echo the need to protect this iconic species before they are lost from the world’s oceans forever.
As I sit at home writing this piece following the Maluku experience, I’m driven to wonder at the insatiable human appetitive to consume and use the world’s great marine creatures. Aquariums play a valuable role in the conservation of genetic material and linking people in cities to nature. However, aquariums and tourism parks also need to adopt responsible and legal behaviors in sourcing and importing animals, particularly threatened species. And Governments have a duty to encourage social responsibility and to enforce laws and standards, as Indonesia is doing. With significant strides being made in China as to the protection of other animal species, we cannot say we didn’t know. In our 21st century world, with information at our fingertips, ignorance is just not an excuse.

Support the work of the International League of Conservation Photographers by donating at this link.

Comments

  1. Teresa Wagner
    U.S.
    June 7, 12:28 am

    “However, aquariums and tourism parks also need to adopt responsible and legal behaviors in sourcing and importing animals, particularly threatened species.”

    Do you truly think that species that are not threatened suffer less in captivity? They ALL suffer.